We have more ABM tools than ever. Intent platforms, CDPs, programmatic display, AI-powered sequencing, identity resolution, and multi-touch attribution dashboards that make your CFO feel like they’re getting their money’s worth. The stack has never been more sophisticated.
And yet.
Are the companies actually winning enterprise deals right now? They’re hosting 10-person dinners and sending $7 bags of gummy worms.
I’m not being cute. Listen to any recent conversation with the ABM leads at Snowflake, Ramp, or Hightouch. What they’re prioritizing isn’t another layer of digital orchestration. It’s getting in the room. Physical, analog, human presence.
Here’s the thing, though: I don’t think most teams realize how deeply we over-indexed on digital coming out of COVID. Events died. Gifting felt awkward because nobody knew anyone’s home address. We built stacks instead of relationships. And now we’re all staring at the same fatigued buyers, wondering why our engagement metrics are in the toilet.
The Fatigue Is Real
Sendoso’s 2026 Digital Fatigue Report surveyed 425 marketers and analyzed 1.75 million gifts. The numbers are damning:
· 84% of buyers are fatigued by cold calls
· 83% fatigued by marketing emails
· 82% fatigued by sales emails
· 78% fatigued by digital ads
Eighty-four percent. Fatigued. By the channels we spend most of our budgets on.
We optimized for volume and burned through buyer attention in the process. This isn’t a hot take anymore. It’s just the state of B2B. Your buyers are tired of you before you’ve even said hello.
And look, I’ve written before about how paid media isn’t the problem in isolation. A channel can’t outperform the system it sits in. But the system most teams built over the last four years treats digital as the entirety of the motion rather than as one node in it. That’s the mistake.
We’ve been nominated by Demand & Expand in the best newsletter category. Your vote would count for alot (and takes 10 seconds)
https://www.demandandexpand.com/awards
P.S You can also get 20% off tickets by using the code 42agency
The Channels Nobody Uses
Here’s where it gets interesting. The same Sendoso report asked about zero fatigue by channel. Meaning: what percentage of buyers report no exhaustion whatsoever with each channel type?
· Direct mail and gifts: 40%
· In-person events: 34%
· Virtual events: 32%
· Marketing emails: 17%
· Cold calls: 16%
The two channels buyers aren’t tired of are both physical.
But here’s the kicker: only 34% of marketing teams report using gifting or direct mail regularly. It’s the least-used channel despite being the least fatiguing. We’re all fighting for scraps in channels that are saturated while ignoring the ones where buyers are actually receptive.
Why? Because physical is harder. Doesn’t scale as elegantly. Can’t be measured in the same neat dashboards. So we don’t do it.
This is backwards.
What the Winning Teams Actually Do
Let me tell you what’s actually working at the companies everyone benchmarks against.
Snowflake runs intimate dinners where existing customers share experiences directly with prospects. Casey Patterson, their Director of ABM, talks about this constantly. The model isn’t vendor pitch. It’s peer-to-peer trust. Get a happy customer in a room with three prospects who have the same problem. Let them talk. Your sales rep barely needs to speak.
They’re also doing data-driven personalized gifts. Not mass swag drops. Intentional, researched gifts that demonstrate you paid attention.
Ramp takes a different angle. Drew Pinta, their Director of Growth Data Science, describes “hyper-specific dinners where the salesperson originates the idea based on a specific pain point.” The key phrase there is salesperson originates. This isn’t marketing deciding to host a generic networking event. It’s sales saying “I have three prospects stuck on the same objection, let’s get them in a room together.”
Problem-focused gatherings. Not happy hours.
Hightouch does high-end executive experiences. Brian Kotlyar, their CMO, talks about moving beyond simple swag to meaningful experiences for strategic accounts. They layer it: scaled gifting through platforms like Sendoso for the broader ABM list, plus personalized high-effort gifts for the accounts that really matter.
The common thread? All three companies prioritize offline, high-touch tactics over digital ads for ABM engagement. They haven’t abandoned digital. But they understand it’s Layer 1 and 2 work. The closing happens in person.
The $7 Gummy Worms
There’s a story in the Sendoso report that stuck with me.
The best gift a buyer ever received from a vendor? It wasn’t a $200 bottle of whiskey. It was a $7 bag of sour gummy worms.
The context: she had mentioned her daughter loved them. Some rep was actually listening. Wrote it down. Remembered. Sent a bag with a handwritten note.
Seven dollars and active listening beat two hundred dollars and generic “thought you’d enjoy this.”
The data backs this up. When asked what gifts they prefer:
· 34% want branded high-quality swag
· 26% want a thoughtful, personalized low-value gift
· 23% want a generic gift card
· 12% want a generic high-value item
A quarter of buyers actively prefer the cheap-but-personal option over the expensive-but-generic one. And here’s the list of what to avoid:
1. Compliance violations (obviously)
2. Hassle (signatures, forms, anything requiring effort)
3. Low-quality swag (the branded stress ball nobody asked for)
4. Alcohol (only 54% of adults drink regularly, lowest in 87 years)
5. Too personal (creepy social snooping vibes)
6. Too expensive (feels like a bribe, creates obligation)
The sweet spot is thoughtful, low-friction, and personal. Not expensive.
I’ve recommended this before: research where decision makers went to school. Buy alumni swag and ship it. It’s $40 and a clear signal that you did your homework. You’re not being creepy. You’re being considerate.
Why Teams Don’t Do This
I know what you’re thinking. All of this sounds lovely, but it doesn’t scale. My board isn’t going to be impressed by “we sent some cupcakes.”
Let me address the objections directly.
“It doesn’t scale.”
True. That’s the point. ABM isn’t about scale. ABM is selling to your top 10-50 dream accounts. If you’re trying to run gifting and dinners at the scale of your programmatic display campaigns, you’ve misunderstood the exercise.
ABM is not a renamed demand gen motion. It’s a focused effort on accounts that matter disproportionately. If the list is too long to do this for, the list is wrong.
“It’s hard to measure.”
Measure deal velocity, not MQLs. Are your ABM deals closing faster? Are they larger? Did the buyer attend a dinner before they signed?
Deal velocity is everything in enterprise GTM: (Number of Deals x Average Deal Value x Conversion Rate) / Sales Cycle Length. If dinners and gifts are compressing your sales cycle or increasing your close rate, you can measure that. It just requires you to think beyond “how many leads did this generate.”
“Sales won’t do it.”
Then your ABM program is already broken. ABM is a sales activity. Marketing surrounds the market with messaging and air cover. But the actual motion is sales-led. If sales won’t participate in account planning, research, dinner hosting, and gift selection, you don’t have an ABM program. You have marketing pretending to do ABM while sales ignores you.
Fix the alignment problem first.
“It feels old school.”
Old school is the new differentiation.
Everyone else is sending the same cold emails through the same sequences with the same LinkedIn connection requests. The buyer who gets a handwritten note and an invitation to a dinner with three of their peers is going to remember you.
Where This Fits in Your System
Dinners and gifts don’t replace your digital motion. They activate it.
I’ve written about the three layers of enterprise GTM before:
Layer 1: Exposure. Creates familiarity. LinkedIn ads, CTV, podcasts, content. The buyer has heard of you.
Layer 2: Engagement. Reveals interest. Website behavior, intent signals, event attendance. The buyer is exploring.
Layer 3: Activation. Converts interest to conversation. Dinners, gifting, outbound, sales touches. The buyer becomes an opportunity.
Physical tactics belong in Layer 3. They don’t work if you skip Layers 1 and 2.
A targeted dinner invitation works because the buyer already knows who you are. A personalized gift lands because they’ve already been researching you. A well-timed SDR touch converts because you’ve lowered the cost of exploration for a buyer who’s curious but busy.
The anti-pattern is gift card spam to cold accounts. Sending a $50 Starbucks card to someone who’s never heard of you isn’t ABM. It’s expensive noise. You haven’t earned the right to their attention yet.
Do the work in Layers 1 and 2 first.
The Playbook
If you’re ready actually to do this, here’s how I’d think about it.
When to run dinners:
· Pain-point specific (Ramp model), not generic networking
· 8-12 people max
· Mix customers and prospects (Snowflake model)
· Sales-originated idea, marketing executes logistics
· Quarterly in your key markets, not one-off experiments
When to gift:
· Deal acceleration (active opportunity, stuck deal)
· Post-meeting thank you (not pre-meeting bribe)
· Milestone moments (closed-won anniversary, expansion conversations)
· Personalized beats expensive (the gummy worms rule)
When NOT to gift:
· Cold outreach to unaware accounts
· Generic blasts to a list
· Without CRM infrastructure to track it
How to measure:
· Deal velocity (are ABM deals closing faster?)
· Average deal size (are they bigger?)
· Influenced pipeline (did they attend or receive something before closing?)
· NOT: MQLs, gift acceptance rate in isolation
The measurement frame matters. If you’re trying to justify dinners and gifts with the same metrics you use for paid media, you’ll kill the program before it starts. These tactics don’t generate leads. They accelerate deals and build relationships. Measure accordingly.
The Takeaway
The ABM stack isn’t the strategy. The strategy is getting in rooms with the right people and being remembered.
Snowflake, Ramp, and Hightouch aren’t winning because they have better intent data. They’re winning because they host dinner. They’re winning because they listen well enough to remember someone’s daughter likes sour gummy worms.
The Sendoso data proves that buyers aren’t tired of physical. They’re tired of digital. But the vast majority of marketing teams are still pouring budget into the fatigued channels while ignoring the ones with open attention.
This only works as Layer 3 of a system. You still need exposure and engagement. You still need the digital infrastructure. But you also need to close the loop with something human.
The companies that win the next five years of enterprise deals will be the ones that remember how to shake hands.
So here’s my question: when’s the last time you actually got in a room with your top five accounts?
Sources: Sendoso 2026 Digital Fatigue Report; Exit Five podcast, “ABM: What Ramp, Snowflake, and Hightouch are doing in 2026” (February 2026).